Is Bing too smart?
Today I was running through some competitor research for a new Page 1 Solutions client, an eye doctor in Maryland, and one of the terms I chose for analysis was “Maryland Glaucoma”. For Google and Yahoo! the search results were exactly what you would expect to see: Maryland-based web sites, mostly belonging to eye doctors who treat glaucoma.
And then there were the results from Bing. (You know where this is going…)
The first result is an Iowa .edu site that has no mention of Maryland. The second result is the WebMD entry on glaucoma, which has nothing to do with Maryland. Three and four were Maryland-based, but then the rest of the results were about split 50/50 between Maryland-area results and others from places as random as Chicago and San Francisco. That’s some really fuzzy geography… What the heck, Bing?
Then it dawned on me while skimming the results that Bing was highlighting a description term I hadn’t even searched for: MD.
Why is it throwing MD in there when I didn’t ask for it? Well, Bing’s search algorithm is smart. In fact, it is smart enough to know that MD is the postal code for Maryland, and it oh-so-helpfully assumes that if I’m searching “Maryland glaucoma”, then I’ll also want results for “MD glaucoma”. Right? Right! How intuitive and clever!
Well, not really. That may work for Minnesota or New Jersey, but here’s the thing - Bing forgot the part where MD doesn’t only stand for Maryland. It also means “medical doctor”, and pairing it with a medical term like glaucoma only confuses things. Bing has failed to take the abbreviation’s context into account when returning search results, and this could throw a wrench in optimizing certain localizations.
A few other potentially problematic postal abbreviations?
Pennsylvania = PA = physician’s assistant
Colorado = CO = company
Virginia = VA = Veteran’s Administration
Idaho = ID = identification
Puerto Rico = PR = public relations
Mississippi = MS = multiple sclerosis
What a headache…
We tested our postal code contextual glitch with “Kentucky Breast Augmentation” thinking it might pick up on a connection between “breast” and “KY”, and it thankfully did not. For the most part Bing’s results on similarly structured searches turned out okay, and I don’t think it’s worth worrying about it too much on the front end. However, if your website is hitting page one everywhere but Bing for state-based localization terms, confusion over postal abbreviations is one more suspect to consider.







